It’s a tedious task to keep track of pool chemicals and the proper schedules to use them. However, you can consider a sanitation alternative to make your pool maintenance a bit easier – pool ionizers. Pool ionizers use metallic ions such as copper and silver to eliminate algae and other pathogens in the water.
Below, I will walk through everything you need to know about pool ionizers, including their effectiveness, benefits, common problems, cost, and more.
What Is a Pool Ionizer?
A pool ionizer is a sanitizing product that usually contains silver and copper ions. These elements are effective in neutralizing the effects of bacteria and algae. Copper has been a popular anti-microbial substance for hundreds of years, and it’s also commonly found in algaecides. This element is also very effective at stopping algae development, and silver helps eliminate harmful bacteria.
Usually, a swimming pool ionizer is an electronic tool that you integrate into your pool’s filter and pump system. However, solar pool ionizers are becoming increasingly popular and are cheaper when compared to electronic types. A solar pool ionizer works differently because it floats around in the swimming pool during the cleaning process.
A pool ionizer works in the following ways:
- The ionizer brings water in through a suction line, pump, filter, and heater. Then it sanitizes the water before it goes back to the pool through return jets.
- The ionizer runs a low voltage DC to activate the electrodes and trigger their sanitizing capabilities.
- The flow of electricity causes the silver and copper to lose electrons, converting them into cations. These are ions with a positive charge and a significantly higher number of protons than electrons.
- The cations then get into the pool through the water and then contact the ionizer. These elements stay in the water until they come across a substance that has negatively charged ions. These ions have a negative charge as they contain more electrons than protons.
- Finally, the cations connect to the anionic microorganisms, leading to the breakdown of cell walls. However, while an ionizer helps clean your pool, you need to use a chemical sanitizer as well.
Do Pool Ionizers Work? Effectiveness vs. Traditional Systems
Pool ionizers contain ions that are powerful in eliminating harmful impurities in your pool water. However, you should still use the pool ionizer along with another cleaning product like chlorine. Below are some shared pool cleaning systems and how they compare to pool ionizers.
- Saltwater chlorinators: Saltwater chlorinators convert salt into chlorine using a specialized generator. You pour a specific amount of salt into the pool and let the generator work its magic. However, the generator requires maintenance, and you have to carefully track the pool salt levels.
- Pool bromine: Bromine functions in the same way as chlorine. In fact, they come from the same chemical category. However, bromine is more expensive and unsuitable for areas that experience excessive sunlight. You can learn more about the pros and cons in my full article on bromine vs. chlorine.
- UV Pool system: UV pool sanitation provides a chemical-free alternative for cleaning your pool. However, it is only effective for areas with lots of sunlight and doesn’t clean the pool as thoroughly as chemical-based products.
Mineral Systems vs. Pool Ionizer
A mineral system is very similar to a pool ionizer. Both systems generally use copper and silver to kill microbes, but a mineral system contains cartridges filled with the minerals and releases the particles directly into the water, rather than using an electric charge to release ions.
Both mineral systems and pool ionizers require another type of sanitizer, but ionizers will need replacement parts less frequently.
How Long Do Pool Ionizers Last?
On average, expect pool ionizers to last between 6-12 months. The two rods, which contain silver and copper, gradually degrade over time. This is because the rods release ions into the water, which breaks down their potency.
Eventually, these rods need replacement to ensure optimal cleaning results. A few other helpful factors to consider in the longevity of pool ionizers include:
- Quality of the silver and copper ions
- Amount of water requiring filtration
- Amount of time you want to use the filtration system
- Quality of pool ionizer installation
Benefits of Pool Ionizers
Once installed correctly in your pool system, a pool ionizer can have a lot of benefits.
Most pools become dirty due to algae or other particles in water. Usually, these particles are too small to filter and may keep circulating. The ionizer’s positively charged silver and copper ions help remove these negatively charged impurities.
Reduces the Need for Using Chlorine
Pool ionizers work well to remove impurities such as bacteria and algae, which reduces the amount of chlorine needed in your swimming pool. However, this does not mean that you can stop using chlorine completely.
While the ionizer will work well for removing impurities, you still have to mix it with small amounts of chlorine. The chemical amount required depends on the size of your pool and its water capacity. If you don’t know that number, check out my pool volume calculator.
Easy on Pool Components
Chemicals such as chlorine and bromine have corrosive effects over time, mainly when used as sole pool cleaning products. Corrosion can easily compromise your materials over time.
Any corroding pool components threaten the water quality and your ability to keep the pool clean. So since a pool ionizer reduces the need for using chlorine, it improves the longevity of pool components.
Safe for the Skin and Eyes
Many swimmers complain of reactions such as rashes, itchy skin, and red eyes from chlorine pools.
Chlorine is a potent chemical substance known to be irritating for people with sensitivity issues. So a pool ionizer reduces the likelihood of experiencing such problems.
Common Problems with Pool Ionizers
Here are some drawbacks to be mentioned about pool ionizers.
Many pool owners struggle with configuring pool ionizers, eventually leading to staining issues. Staining occurs because the metals dissolve in the water. Plus, the stains might also be present due to the compromised functions of the pool ionizer. You should reconfigure the system and get a suitable metal water filter system when this happens.
Pool ionizers are prone to impurities, especially if you have hard water. If deposits from hard water are affecting your ionizer, remove any deposits that might accumulate on the electrodes in your ionizer. Using this approach regularly will ensure your ionizer cell lasts longer.
The Results Are Slow
Ionizers are not known to be the fastest pool system. It can take up to two weeks for the silver and copper ions to accumulate adequately in the water.
It may also take a few more days for the ionizers to give their full water purification results.
Requires a Residual Cleaning Method
While chlorine-free pools are technically possible, ionizers typically require another sanitizer to keep your pool clean.
The ionizers are powerful in eliminating bacteria, but they don’t perform oxidation procedures. So they cannot stop a significant number of microbial types and organic materials.
Bacteria often evolve genetically, which eventually compromises the pool ionizer’s ability to be effective. So it’s good to be aware of your pool purification needs.
Research has shown that bacteria species such as Pseudomonas are the most commonly resistant types.
Cost of Pool Ionizers
Pool ionizers average between $100 and $600 for small to average-sized pools. However, expect these costs to increase to up to $2,000 for larger or public swimming pools.
The solar types are the cheapest because they don’t feature the same components as their electrical counterparts.
Various other factors come into play in the cost of pool ionizers, including:
- The brand of pool ionizer: Some brands put a lot more care and quality materials into their manufacturing process, which is reflected in the price.
- The functions it can perform: Expect an ionizer with several capabilities at a slightly higher cost than other basic alternatives.
- The quality of copper and silver ions: This is vital as this determines their longevity and ability to remove impurities from the water.
How Pool Ionizers Affect Water Chemistry
It is important to keep in mind that using a pool ionizer will change the ideal chemical ranges for your pool. Here is a quick and easy guide that shows these new levels:
- Alkaline levels: 80-120ppm
- Calcium hardness: 200-300ppm
- Chlorine: 0.5-0.8 ppm
- pH: 7.2-7.6
Get My Free Pool Care Checklist
Download my free, printable pool maintenance checklist to help you accomplish regular pool care tasks for any type of swimming pool.
At the end of the day, a pool ionizer might be perfect for your outdoor pool. As long as you still use some chlorine, you’ll have a beautifully clean pool. The benefit is that the ionizer reduces the need for other sanitizers.
Have a question? Let me know; always happy to lend a hand.